@mkhl was kind enough to do a drive-by review of my proposed changes,
which I'll include here as the GitHub URI may bit-rot over time (it's
technically
[here](bc21caa0d5),
but that commit isn't part of the `beets` repo, so may get GC'd).
I've encorporated all their proposed changes, as their code is being run
against an existing Beets library, whereas my changes were made as I
tried to set up Beets for the first time - thus I'm inclined to trust
their known-working code more than my own!
This is a review starting at
bc21caa0d5 (diff-d53f73df7f26990645e7bdac865ef86a52b67bafc6fe6ad69890b510a57e2955R210)
(`class DelimeteredString(String):`)
> for context this is the version i'm using now:
>
> ```python
> class DelimitedString(String):
> model_type = list
>
> def __init__(self, delimiter):
> self.delimiter = delimiter
>
> def format(self, value):
> return self.delimiter.join(value)
>
> def parse(self, string):
> if not string:
> return []
> return string.split(self.delimiter)
>
> def to_sql(self, model_value):
> return self.delimiter.join(model_value)
> ```
>
> i think 'delimited string' is the correct term here
>
> the rest of the code doesn't seem to use many abbreviations, so calling the property `delimiter` seems appropriate
>
> i don't think a default value for the delimiter makes a lot of sense?
>
> the list comprehension and string conversions in `to_sql` don't seem necessary to me, see above. did you run into trouble without them?
>
> the `from_sql` seems to just be missing functionality from the `Type` parent and seems completely unnecessary
>
> `parse` shouldn't be able to fail because at that point, we've ensured that its argument is actually a string. i also added a `if not string` condition because otherwise the empty list of album types would turn into the list containing the empty string (because that's what split returns)
>
> if we don't define a `format` method here we print the internal python representation of the values (i.e. `['album', 'live']` or somesuch) in the `beet write` output. joining on the delimiter nicely formats the output :)
>
> just so i don't ping you twice unnecessarily, i think it's better to instantiate this type with `'; '` (semicolon space) as the delimiter, because that's what was used before to join the albumtypes and what we'll find in the database
All these changes have been made, including the switch from `;` to
`;<space>` as the in-DB separator.
7cfc39ea27